Status: open · gathering (evidence being collected) · answered (→ synthesis file).
Q1 · How do the four lecturers read《素問・上古天真論》? — open
All four series cover the 黃帝內經: 徐文兵 (with 梁冬), 南懷瑾, 倪海廈《人紀・內經》, 游朱義. Compare their readings of the opening (昔在黃帝…成而登天), 法於陰陽／和於術數, and the 真人・至人・聖人・賢人 grades. Inputs: L3 of each speaker's relevant talks.
Q2 · Interpretive method: 字形訓詁 vs. 經文注疏 vs. 臨床 — open
徐文兵 argues heavily from character structure (靈 = 雨＋三口＋巫; 覡; 動作 = 踵＋手) — xu-001. How common is this per speaker, and how do the decompositions compare with 《說文解字》? Track as L3 insights of type 文字訓詁.
Q3 · Claims that could be studied empirically — open
Collect L3 "可研究／可驗證之主張" across talks (e.g. xu-001: limb function as early marker of declining 氣血 — 「人老先老腿」).
Q4 · Factual / identification checks — gathering
- xu-001 [00:04:09] 「雙橋老太太鄧老太太」— 雙橋老太太 is generally identified as 羅有明 (bone-setter). Speaker slip or ASR? Needs audio check.
- xu-001 [00:02:34] attributes 《漢書・藝文志》 listing to 劉向; the 藝文志 is 班固's, based on 劉向／劉歆's 《七略》 — note, don't correct the speaker.
- you-zhuyi-097, -099: YouTube captions end before the video ends (mid-thought) — upstream pipeline should re-check caption completeness / consider ASR fill.